It was a busy week for the copyright lawyers over at HYBE, as the kpop giant was hit with not one but two separate infringement lawsuits over songs by BTS and NewJeans.
In a case filed Tuesday, a company called All Surface Publishing claimed that the 2023 NewJeans song “ETA,” a minor hit, stole multiple elements from an instrumental dance track called “Samir’s Theme” that had been released nearly two decades earlier.
Then on Wednesday (July 8), an even bigger claim: That BTS’s “Swim” — a smash hit that debuted at No. 1 on the Hot 100 as the lead track off ARIRANG and spent 15 weeks on the chart — lifted material from an unpublished demo by three little-known songwriters. The case cited an expert report that “unequivocally” concludes the BTS track copied the earlier song.
The report’s author, musicologist Alexander Stewart, is a name music lawyers will recognize. He was retained by the accusers in the high-profile copyright case against Ed Sheeran over Marvin Gaye’s “Let’s Get It On,” as well as by the plaintiffs in a similar infringement case against Led Zeppelin over “Stairway To Heaven.”
In both cases, of course, those claims were later rejected by juries.
You’re reading The Legal Beat, a weekly newsletter about music law from Billboard Pro, offering you a one-stop cheat sheet of big new cases, important rulings and all the fun stuff in between. To get the newsletter in your inbox every Tuesday, subscribe here.
Other top stories this week…
-It ain’t over yet: A self-published Florida poet who claims Taylor Swift stole lyrics filed a quick appeal less than two days after her latest copyright case against the superstar was thrown out of court.
-Puerto Rico’s Supreme Court ruled Bad Bunny’s ex-girlfriend can keep suing the star for allegedly using her voice without permission on the chart-topping album Un Verano Sin Ti.
-In yet more HYBE news: The label initiated legal action to curb the sale of knockoff BTS merch during U.S. stops of the superstar K-pop group’s blockbuster ARIRANG world tour.
–Boosie Badazz paid $600,000 to a pair of lobbyists to seek a pardon from President Donald Trump and is now taking legal action to demand a refund after it never materialized.
-A New York appeals court rejected 50 Cent’s request to automatically win a lawsuit against an ex-girlfriend over her “tell-all” Instagram posts — not a huge shock after how arguments went.
-A judge issued an early-stage ruling in the legal battle between Fuerza Regida and its label Rancho Humilde, saying it was too early to decide the case’s core question about the band’s record deal.
-StubHub was hit with a class action in the wake of reporting that its CEO is also the managing partner of a ticket broker that has made millions of dollars on the platform.
–Nicki Minaj allegedly owes $230,000 in legal bills to lawyers who defended her against recent accusations of copyright infringement and is facing a looming default judgment.
-The composer of the Zulu chant from The Lion King’s “Circle of Life” dropped his lawsuit against a comedian who joked about the song on a podcast. But the case isn’t over quite yet.
-Insomniac Events reached a settlement that will keep the global dance music company involved in two Miami venues following a protracted legal battle.
-iHeartMedia agreed resolved an investigation by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) into whether the radio giant offers artists airplay in exchange for free event performances.
-The rock band Lit reached a settlement to end an $800,000 lawsuit against Sony Music over streaming royalties for “My Own Worst Enemy and the rest of their ’90s catalog.
–Sam Smith and Normani once again asked a judge to throw out a never-ending copyright case over their 2019 hit “Dancing With a Stranger,” arguing the case “does not come close” to succeeding.
